Before Jeremy Lin got the starting nod a few weeks ago, no one would have ever guess that a guy who no one had ever heard of would have turned the NBA world on its ear in only 9 games. To Lin’s credit he has propelled his underperforming team to an 8-1 record since he got the starting nod and had as hot a start in terms of points and assists as some of the greatest players who have ever played the game, including Magic Johnson, Isiah Thomas and John Stockton among others. However, does that mean Jeremy Lin is the real deal and on par with those all-time greats or is Lin’s hot start fueled by hype and merely a product of being at the right place at the right time? While most people have signed off on Lin there are a couple of reasons why it would be wise to wait before punching Lin’s ticket to the Hall-of-Fame.
HE PLAYS FOR THE KNICKS
Today’s New York Knicks are far removed from the Knicks of the early 1970s championship teams, and except for a couple of flare-ups during the mid to late 90s, it is pretty fair to say that the Knicks have been pretty underwhelming franchise for the last few decades. Yet, the New York Knicks for whatever reason remain New York’s team. That’s right, despite other New York franchises bringing home the titles at a much more frequent clip (i.e. Yankees, Giants), basketball still dominates all things in New York and so the spot light remains perpetually on the Knicks. Add to this the fact that New York is the biggest sports market in North America coupled with the amount of time the Knicks have not won a title, plus the hype and hope Knicks fans had after the Carmelo Anthony signing, and an ordinary team like the Knicks suddenly has 100x greater spotlight on it than your average team (my math skills are subpar but this seems about right).
How does this relate to Jeremy Lin? Well given that there is such a prevalent spotlight on the Knicks, anything that happens on this team will received much more exposure than anywhere else whether it is actually worth obsessing over or it is not. And while Jeremy Lin has done a tremendous job of taking his team all the way to .500, there is no doubt that if he was playing on the Bucks, Warriors or Bobcats that his achievements would not receive the same level of attention.
HE PLAYS FOR MIKE D’ANTONI’s KNICKS
Maybe you do not follow basketball all that closely, but the coach of the Knicks is Mike D’Antoni, a coach who is known as a tremendous up-tempo offensive coach, but who is also known to place little to no emphasis on defense. The result? His team and its individual players put up eye-popping stats, but the statistic that matters most, wins, often is underwhelming (especially come playoff time). Therefore while Lin is putting up the numbers, these numbers given that they are on a Mike D’Antoni team must be taken with a grain of salt. For example, last year Raymond Felton and Wilson Chandler both had “break-out” seasons by the numbers when they played for D’Antoni, but when they were dealt mid season in the Carmelo Anthony trade their numbers tanked worse than NBC’s Playboy Club. Why? Because only on the Knicks can you get away with this brand of one dimensional offense only play (ok maybe it flies in Golden State too) and thus while what Jeremy Lin is doing is eye-popping (especially because the Knicks have also been fortunate enough to get the Ws over this short stretch), does he really merit the hype in light of the Chandler/Felton experiment?
HE PLAYED WITHOUT CARMELO AND AMARE
When Carmelo Anthony was lost to another one of his ailments and Amare Stoudamire missed time due to his personal family tragedy, there was not a single star-level/notable player left on the Knicks who could step up other than Tyson Chandler (and he is known as a defensive guru and only averages about 11 points a game). Where were the points going to come from? Someone else on the roster was going to have to score right? Well luckily for the Knicks Jeremy Lin was someone else and did a tremendous job of filling up the stat sheet (and to his credit the win column) in their absence. But do not think for a minute that if Jeremey Lin had not been the guy to step up that the Knicks would have only scored 50 a game. Why? Because this is the NBA and everyone, even the 11th guy on the bench, can score given the opportunity. Almost nightly a different unknown player puts up 20-30 points a game for a given team because a star is out or having a bad game. So while the Knicks were lucky to have found consistency out of Lin, if it would not have been Lin believe that the other players on the Knicks would have stepped up, gotten the benefit of the extra minutes, got the benefit of the extra touches and put up 20-30 points a game be it Iman Shumpert one night, Tyson Chandler another night, Jarred Jeffries the night after that etc. To summarize, it’s the NBA, everyone can score.
The other thing Lin has going for him is that he is decent (I am just not sure he’s the super-duper star he is already being made out to be). And of course if you are even a half decent player, if you are the only decent guy on your team, of course you are going to get a ton of points. Tracy McGrady killed it with the Magic because the ball was always in his hands, and so if you have no other person to count on, of course your numbers are going to be insane. Does this mean you are as good as every other player in the league who puts up those numbers? No it means you look so good because you are doing it all by yourself. To put up similar numbers while playing with talent the way LeBron James, Kobe Bryant and Kevin Durant do is a much truer indicator of talent (especially if you are getting the Ws with it).
Now that the Knicks roster is getting full again, what with Amar’e coming back, the J.R. Smith signing, Baron Davis on the verge of return and Carmelo near 100%, it will be interesting to see where Lin will rank on a nightly basis on the stat sheet. If he’s a true star he’ll remain the headliner, if he’s just ok the middle and if he’s terrible the bottom. That’s just how the stat sheet works.
HIS TURN-OVERS ARE BRUTAL
Plain and simple they are brutal. I do not see how any coach, even Mike D’Antoni can allow his PG to average seven turnovers a game without some kind of reprisal be it fewer minutes, fewer plays or getting benched for quarters or halfs. Turnovers kills momentum and most coaches will tell you that over the long haul there is no greater indicators for losing then turnovers.
IT HAS ONLY BEEN 9 GAMES!!!!!!!!!
I have no idea where this rush to anoint comes from in sports, but if you read my entries regularly you know what it is what I hate most. Every player who comes out and plays well initially, is swept up in this media whirlwind hurricane and talked about and hyped relentlessly. And not only is this hype train incredibly irritating, it is loud mindless chatter until a sufficient time has passed and a sufficient number of games are played in order to establish the appropriate sample size necessary to test whether or not the player is for real or just a flash in the pan. But for whatever reason, as soon as a new player gets going, the hype train gets going and every media outlet aboard.
I know I am not naïve enough to believe that this done out of sheer stupidity or coincidence, obviously these rush to anoint stories are incredibly popular and put a lot of dollars into a lot of people’s pockets, especially in slow news cycles, but for the integrity of the game I would please ask the media outlets and fans to be patient, and let enough games pass before rushing to crown every flare-up as the next big thing.
Whether or Jeremy Lin is a true superstar will only be ascertained over many more games and how he plays on a team with a full roster. He could be the real thing but in the words of Bill Parcells, “”We’ve got a ways to go here. So put away the anointing oil, OK?”